The New York Yankees’ 2025 roster construction has taken an intriguing turn as they navigate the relief pitcher market. Despite the availability of elite left-hander Tanner Scott, the organization has pivoted toward more economical options, including Andrew Chafin, Tim Hill, and Brooks Raley. This calculated approach reflects a broader strategy of balancing competitive needs with fiscal responsibility.

The Yankees’ current priorities

Brendan Kuty of The Athletic has shed light on the Yankees’ bullpen strategy, revealing their concentrated effort to acquire left-handed relief help. In his January 15 analysis, Kuty outlined the team’s interest in several cost-effective options, highlighting how the organization is prioritizing value over star power.

“As of Tuesday, the team’s biggest priority seemed to be adding a left-handed reliever, with names such as Tim Hill, Brooks Raley, and Andrew Chafin each being discussed, according to a league source,” Kuty reported.

These targets represent a deliberate approach to bullpen construction, balancing effectiveness with the realities of luxury tax considerations that increasingly influence roster decisions.

Andrew Chafin: The veteran option

bigcountry1739@insta
Andrew Chafin has emerged as a compelling candidate for the Yankees’ left-handed relief vacancy. His appeal lies in a combination of seasoned experience and demonstrated effectiveness against batters from both sides of the plate. Particularly noteworthy are his platoon splits, where he’s proven especially tough on left-handed hitters, who managed just a .317 slugging percentage against him, compared to a still-respectable .353 mark by right-handed batters.

This versatility aligns perfectly with the Yankees’ needs, as noted by Jon Heyman of The New York Post, who identified Chafin as a priority target in December 2024. His ability to handle diverse roles makes him an attractive option for a team seeking bullpen flexibility.

Why not Tanner Scott?

Athlon Sport
The Yankees’ decision to bypass Tanner Scott, despite his remarkable 2024 performance, reflects practical financial considerations rather than any doubt about his abilities. Scott’s dominant campaign, split between Miami and San Diego, yielded impressive numbers: a 9-6 record, 1.75 ERA, and 84 strikeouts across 72 innings. However, his anticipated price tag has steered the Yankees toward alternative options.

MLB.com’s recent reporting indicates the Yankees’ estimated luxury tax payroll for 2025 already exceeds $303 million, pushing against the highest threshold. This financial reality has prompted a more measured approach to bullpen reinforcement.

The financial equation

The Yankees’ fiscal strategy has become increasingly sophisticated as they balance roster improvement with payroll management. Their focus on relievers like Chafin, Hill, and Raley rather than pursuing Scott demonstrates a commitment to finding value while maintaining financial flexibility.

A potential solution to their payroll constraints could come through trading Marcus Stroman, who carries an $18.5 million salary for 2025 and an $18 million vesting option for 2026. Moving Stroman could create the financial latitude needed to address multiple roster needs, including their second base vacancy.

Strengthening an already potent bullpen

TNYT
The Yankees’ reluctance to pursue Scott should not be interpreted as compromising bullpen quality. Their recent acquisition of elite closer Devin Williams, combined with Luke Weaver‘s continued presence, provides a strong foundation. Adding any of their targeted left-handed options would further enhance an already formidable relief corps.

The addition of Chafin, Hill, or Raley would introduce valuable left-handed depth while maintaining the bullpen’s overall effectiveness. Each pitcher brings unique capabilities that could strengthen the relief unit in different ways.

The case for each target

Andrew Chafin: His track record of consistency and ability to handle high-pressure situations make him an ideal fit. Chafin’s balanced performance against both lefties and righties provides the tactical flexibility that modern bullpens require.
Tim Hill: Having previously pitched for the Yankees in 2024, Hill offers familiarity with the organization’s expectations. His distinctive sidearm delivery creates matchup advantages that could prove valuable in crucial situations.
Brooks Raley: Raley’s reliability and experience in high-leverage moments make him an attractive option. His steady performance record suggests he could seamlessly integrate into the Yankees’ bullpen hierarchy.

The bigger picture

The Yankees’ decision to pursue value options over Tanner Scott reflects a mature understanding of roster construction and resource allocation. By targeting relievers like Chafin, Hill, and Raley, they maintain the flexibility to address multiple needs while building a competitive bullpen.

As spring training approaches, the Yankees‘ methodical approach to roster construction continues to evolve. Their pursuit of left-handed relief help, while staying within financial parameters, demonstrates how modern baseball operations must balance competitive ambitions with practical constraints. Whether through one of their identified targets or another solution, the Yankees remain focused on assembling a championship-caliber roster for 2025.