As the countdown to Spring Training enters its final phase, the New York Yankees’ third base situation remains unresolved. Into this uncertainty steps actor Nick Turturro, whose passionate advocacy for acquiring Alex Bregman has captured the attention of the Yankees’ faithful.

The outspoken superfan chose Instagram as his platform on Thursday to present a compelling argument for pursuing the accomplished infielder, emphasizing performance over past rivalries.

Turturro’s passionate appeal to Yankees

With characteristic enthusiasm, Turturro delivered an emphatic endorsement of the former Astros star:

“I want to talk about somebody I like, somebody who’s a personal friend of mine. I know he played for the enemy, I know he played for the Houston Astros. I don’t give a s***, he’s a winner. *Alex Bregman, third base, we need that pedigree.*

“LeMahieu is not going to cut it, he’s done. Cabrera is not the answer. You could shift Jazz over to second, Alex can slide right in. Give him 3-4 years, what are you waiting for? We need another big bat. Bregman is the guy, I’m telling you. Don’t go cheap, go the right way. Sign the dude. I like him, I know we’ll be very happy with him. Please, sign the guy.”

Yankees’ incomplete roster transformation

AP
While the Yankees’ front office has orchestrated several significant moves this offseason, including the acquisitions of Max Fried, Cody Bellinger, and Paul Goldschmidt, their infield composition remains uncertain. The absence of a definitive solution at third base stands in stark contrast to their aggressive pursuit of talent in other areas.

The current strategy appears to favor a platoon system involving DJ LeMahieu, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza. However, this arrangement presents several vulnerabilities: LeMahieu’s recent injury-related decline, Cabrera’s offensive inconsistency, and Peraza’s limited major league experience all raise concerns about the position’s stability.

The case for Bregman in pinstripes

Alex Bregman’s credentials make him an intriguing solution to the Yankees’ third base vacancy. The 30-year-old free agent brings an impressive combination of offensive production, defensive reliability, and championship experience. His career statistics tell a compelling story:

.276 Batting Average
175+ Career Home Runs
Two Silver Slugger Awards
Two-Time World Series Champion (2017, 2022)

His approach at the plate, characterized by a stellar .370 career on-base percentage, aligns perfectly with the Yankees’ offensive philosophy emphasizing disciplined at-bats and consistent production.

But Yankees’ hesitation raises questions

The Yankees‘ apparent reluctance to pursue Bregman has drawn attention from baseball insiders, including MLB analyst Jeff Passan, who recently expressed bewilderment at the team’s stance.

“It’s wild to me that Alex Bregman is sitting out there right now and the Yankees aren’t in on him.” (via Talkin’ Yanks)

This sentiment reflects growing industry consensus about the logical fit between player and team, making the Yankees’ current position increasingly difficult to justify.

Exploring alternative solutions

Lachlan Cunningham
While Bregman represents the most straightforward solution, the Yankees have reportedly explored other options, including Nolan Arenado of the St. Louis Cardinals. However, acquiring Arenado would necessitate a significant prospect package, whereas Bregman could be secured through free agency without depleting organizational depth.

The proximity of Spring Training adds urgency to these deliberations, as the Yankees must soon commit to either their internal options or pursue external reinforcement.

Decision point: Championship dreams vs. fiscal restraint

Turturro’s impassioned plea resonates with a fanbase eager to see their team maximize its championship potential in 2025. His message—”Don’t go cheap, go the right way”—encapsulates the sentiment of many observers who view third base as the final piece in an otherwise championship-caliber roster.

The Yankees‘ historical willingness to acquire elite talent when pursuing championships suggests this situation merits serious consideration. Their aggressive approach this offseason indicates an organizational commitment to contention, making their hesitation regarding third base particularly noteworthy.

As Brian Cashman and the Yankees’ front office weigh their options, the possibility of adding Bregman—or another impact player—remains viable. The resolution of this situation could significantly influence the team’s championship aspirations, making it one of the most intriguing storylines of the remaining offseason.

The coming weeks will reveal whether the Yankees heed Turturro’s advice and pursue a transformative addition at third base, or maintain their current course with internal options. Either way, their decision will have substantial implications for their 2025 championship pursuit.