As the Montreal Canadiens wrap up another challenging season, the focus quickly shifts from on-ice action to off-season speculation and debate—a familiar ritual for fans and analysts in Quebec. With the playoffs out of reach, attention now turns to the future and the bold moves that could shape the franchise’s destiny. This week, a particularly explosive idea ignited heated conversation on TVA Sports, when host Jean-Charles Lajoie and analyst Philippe Boucher discussed the possibility of a one-for-one trade between the Canadiens and the New York Rangers, involving two former first overall picks: Juraj Slafkovsky and Alexis Lafrenière.

The mere suggestion of swapping these two young stars has sent shockwaves through both fanbases, raising passionate arguments on both sides. While some see the deal as a fresh start for two talented players who have faced immense pressure since entering the NHL, others question whether such a move would truly benefit either team. The debate touches on everything from player development and market expectations to the unique pressures of playing in Montreal. As speculation swirls and opinions clash, this hypothetical trade has become the talk of the hockey world—offering a glimpse into the high-stakes decisions that could define the next chapter for both franchises.

Photo credit: NHL

Now that the Montreal Canadiens’ season is over, it’s officially speculation season on various sports platforms in Quebec.

Notably, last night on TVA Sports during Jean-Charles Lajoie’s show, a potential trade between the Montreal Canadiens and the New York Rangers involving Alexis Lafrenière was brought up.

We’re talking about a “one-for-one” trade involving Lafrenière and none other than Juraj Slafkovsky.

If you ask me, I absolutely wouldn’t make this trade.

A Trade Involving Alexis Lafrenière and Juraj Slafkovsky Discussed on TVA Sports

As you can imagine, it’s sparking reactions.

“Should the Montreal Canadiens and the New York Rangers trade two former first overall picks, Juraj Slafkovsky and Alexis Lafrenière, to give them the best chance at success?

That’s the tough question Jean-Charles Lajoie asked his colleague Philippe Boucher.”

– TVA Sports

The pros and cons of a Lafrenière-Slafkovsky trade.

In short, the expert explains that he really likes Slafkovsky and believes people need to be patient with him.

That said, he seems intrigued by the proposal.

“The Montreal market could be good for him,” Boucher acknowledged.

“He performed well when he was under a lot of pressure in Rimouski.
All eyes were on him.”

– TVA Sports

And he concludes by saying he’s not sure he would go through with it, due to the price involved here (Slafkovsky).

All his explanations are in the following article:



21-year-old Juraj Slafkovsky recorded 51 points in 79 games this season, along with 50 points in 82 games last season.

He spent most of his time on the first line and the first power play unit.

23-year-old Alexis Lafrenière tallied 45 points in 82 games this season and 57 points in 82 games the previous season.

He played primarily on the Rangers’ second line and second power play unit.

Both players have similar contracts.. So, would you make this trade?