The future of Sidney Crosby has once again become a hot topic in the hockey world, and this time, the Montreal Canadiens are right at the center of the speculation. In a surprising twist, player agent David Ettedgui has revealed that Crosby was once on the verge of joining the Canadiens as a free agent, only to be strongly discouraged by a former Habs player.

This revelation has reignited conversations about Crosby’s potential move to Montreal, especially as his career with the Pittsburgh Penguins enters a critical phase.

With rumors swirling about the long-term futures of both Crosby and teammate Evgeni Malkin in Pittsburgh, fans and insiders alike are watching closely for any sign of change.

While the identity of the ex-Canadiens player who gave Crosby the controversial advice remains a mystery, the possibility of seeing number 87 in a Canadiens jersey is more intriguing than ever. As the story continues to develop, the hockey world is left wondering: could one of the game’s greatest legends really finish his career in Montreal?

Mar 11, 2025; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby (87) prepares to take a face-off against the Vegas Golden Knights during the first period at PPG Paints Arena. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

Photo credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

Player agent David Ettedgui has just revealed some rather surprising and shocking information regarding Sidney Crosby and the Montreal Canadiens.

While speaking more generally about the situation, he said the following:

“As I had exclusively mentioned several years ago on 91.9 Sport/BPM Sports, if it weren’t for a former Canadiens player who strongly advised him not to sign as a free agent with the Canadiens at the time, Crosby might have already been a Hab for some time now.”

– David Ettedgui

After digging a bit, the identity of that former Canadiens player who strongly advised Crosby against coming to Montreal hasn’t been revealed, but it’s said to be a player who was never very well-liked in the city.

David Ettedgui comments on the Sidney Crosby situation

It’s no secret that plenty of rumors are currently swirling around Pittsburgh Penguins’ number 87, and now the well-connected Ettedgui has added his take.

He arrives at the same conclusions as many other insiders and experts:

– Despite the bad advice from that former Canadiens player, yes, Montreal is absolutely still a potential destination for Crosby-if he decides to finish his career somewhere other than Pittsburgh.

– As for the timing of a possible Canadiens trade for Crosby, Ettedgui also believes it would need to wait at least another year. That lines up with numerous sources suggesting that Crosby wants to finish his career alongside Evgeni Malkin.

If Malkin ends up leaving the Penguins next summer-which is already the plan-then Crosby could follow, unless the Penguins win the Gavin McKenna lottery.

It’ll be a fascinating story to watch unfold.