As the NHL offseason approaches, the future of Mitch Marner with the Toronto Maple Leafs has become one of the league’s hottest topics. With every passing day, speculation grows louder and rumors swirl about where the star forward might land next.

Now, in a twist that few saw coming, the Florida Panthers have emerged as a serious contender in the Marner sweepstakes. This development adds a dramatic new layer to the ongoing saga, especially given the Panthers’ recent history of dashing Toronto’s playoff dreams. As insiders hint at behind-the-scenes conversations and potential blockbuster deals, fans are left anxiously wondering what lies ahead for one of hockey’s most dynamic talents.

The stakes have never been higher, and the outcome could have ripple effects not only for the Maple Leafs and Panthers, but across the entire NHL landscape. With July 1st and the opening of free agency just around the corner, all eyes are on Marner and the decision that could redefine his career—and the fate of two franchises.

May 18, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs forward Mitch Marner (16) adjusts his helmet after a play against the Florida Panthers during the first period of game seven of the second round of the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scotiabank Arena. Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

Photo credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

Every day that goes by seems to add to the Mitch Marner free agency rumors, and now a shocking team, the Florida Panthers, have emerged as a landing spot.

Mitch Marner’s Toronto Maple Leafs future is increasingly uncertain, and a new rumor could hurt fans even more.

Elite Prospects’ Cam Robinson says NHL Draft Combine talk is whispering that Marner might land with the Florida Panthers, a team that has again and again foiled the Leafs’ playoff hopes.

“There’s real smoke that the Florida Panthers could be gearing up to make a run at Marner.

The Panthers, for their credit, are known for their aggressive swings. And this would certainly fall under that category. Marner moves out of the pressure cooker of Toronto to the sunny disposition of Florida with its tax-free status, immaculate vibes, and constant Cup contention.”

– Cam Robinson

Florida may find it difficult to fit Marner under the cap, however

The fit works out on paper, but fiscally, it’s close. Florida is already operating at cap limits, having to re-sign playoff phenom Sam Bennett and star defenseman Aaron Ekblad.

Bennett, the team leader with 13 goals in his first 19 playoff games, has been key to the Panthers’ bid for a second-straight Stanley Cup.

To let him get away for Marner, whose playoff production always seems to wind down, would be a tough move. Meanwhile, the Leafs are reported to be open to a sign-and-trade.

This would involve Toronto signing Marner to an eight-year deal and then trading him to a team of choice for a return while providing Marner with an extra contract year he was unable to get in free agency.

While his playoff performance has been questionable, Marner is on a career-high season with 27 goals, 75 assists, and 102 points. He’s earned 741 points in 657 games and has a +128 plus/minus.

But his playoff performance isn’t as elite: 63 points in 70 games, and in 20 career Games 5-6-7, no goals and seven assists. With July 1st approaching, Marner’s next move could reshape the Leafs, and maybe a divisional foe.