In a twist that few could have predicted, the opening week of the NHL season has already delivered a dramatic storyline involving one of hockey’s most talked-about stars.

Mitch Marner, once the face of the Toronto Maple Leafs and a constant source of both hope and controversy in Canada’s hockey capital, now finds himself navigating unfamiliar waters in Las Vegas. The highly anticipated new chapter of his career with the Golden Knights has taken a surprising turn, leaving fans and analysts alike buzzing with speculation and unanswered questions.

While Toronto seems to be thriving in the early days of the post-Marner era, firing on all cylinders and spreading the scoring wealth across the lineup, Marner’s transition out west has been anything but seamless. Whispers of disappointment and unexpected lineup changes have already begun to circulate, raising eyebrows around the league. Is this just a temporary adjustment period, or could it be the beginning of a much larger story?

As the hockey world watches closely, the stakes are high for both Marner and his new team. What’s really happening behind the scenes in Vegas? How will Marner respond to this early adversity? The answers may surprise you—read on to uncover the full story.

Mitch Marner stretches ahead of a home game in Vegas

Photo credit: @NHL on X

Ex-Toronto Maple Leafs forward Mitch Marner finds himself in the doghouse in Vegas, facing a demotion just a week into the season.

The Toronto Maple Leafs continue their first season of the post Mitch Marner era, coming off a high-scoring 7-4 victory over the Nashville Predators.

The team’s offence looks rejuvenated, spreading the scoring throughout the lineup — something that had been a long-standing challenge during Marner’s tenure in Toronto, due to having a lot less money to go around.

Meanwhile, Marner and the Vegas Golden Knights have started their 2025-26 season with a modest 1-0-2 record. One of their early setbacks came in their season opener, when Marner failed to score in the shootout, leading to a loss.

While it’s still early, the fit between Marner and his new team hasn’t gone entirely as planned.

As noted by Leafs All Day on X:

“Marner already bumped off the top line. Interesting.”

As Leafs All Dayy suggested, Daily Faceoff does indeed have Marner removed from the top line and skating as the team’s 2nd line RW.

image

Marner Demoted from the Top Line After Underwhelming Start

Through his first three games in Vegas, Marner has recorded just two assists, a quiet start for a player expected to be one of the team’s best offensive weapons.

In comparison, his linemate Jack Eichel has exploded out of the gate with seven points in three games, underscoring the production gap and further justifying Marner’s recent demotion from the top line.

It’s an unusual situation for the 28-year-old winger, who was once a cornerstone of the Maple Leafs’ offence and one of Toronto’s most polarizing figures.

His departure from the Leafs came after months of speculation, contract debates, and questions surrounding his fit within the team’s core. Many fans viewed the trade as a necessary change and the end of an era, after a messy breakup.

A Tale of Two Paths

While Toronto appears energized and balanced in their first season without him, Marner is still finding his footing in Vegas. It’s far too early to judge his tenure with the Golden Knights, but his slow start and early demotion highlight how challenging change can be — even for elite players like Marner.

For now, Maple Leafs fans can take comfort in knowing the team seems to be thriving without its former star, while Marner works to prove that his best hockey is still ahead of him.