Controversy has erupted in the hockey world, and this time, it’s not about a game-winning goal or a heated rivalry on the ice.

Instead, a single sentence from a well-known Toronto journalist has sparked a debate reaching far beyond the rink—one that touches on identity, merit, and the very soul of Canadian hockey.

When Steve Simmons published his latest column, few could have predicted the firestorm that would follow.

His remarks about Montreal Canadiens goalie Samuel Montembeault have sent shockwaves through Quebec and the broader hockey community, raising uncomfortable questions about how players are judged and what truly matters in the pursuit of greatness.

But what exactly did Simmons say to provoke such a strong reaction? Why are fans and analysts so outraged, and what does this controversy reveal about the pressures facing athletes in today’s game?

As Montembeault quietly continues to build his reputation with the Canadiens, the spotlight now burns brighter than ever—not for his saves or stats, but for something far more personal.

Is this simply a misunderstanding, or does it point to deeper issues within the sport? The answer may surprise you.

 

Montreal Canadiens Goalie Samuel Montembeault

Photo credit: Sportsnet

In a recent column published in the Toronto Sun, journalist Steve Simmons slammed Montreal Canadiens goalie Samuel Montembeault.

One line that, for many, says a lot way too much. A simple sentence, but heavy with implications.

In a recent article, journalist Steve Simmons made a controversial comment about the Canadiens’ goalie.

“Montembeault is a French-Canadian, which helps his chances to become the third goalie” for Team Canada.

In a single sentence, Simmons doesn’t mention Montembeault’s key saves, his steadily improving stats with the Montreal Canadiens, or his strong performance at the last World Championship.

He doesn’t talk about his reflexes, his calm under pressure, or his tenacity. No. He instead highlights his linguistic background as the main factor for selection.

For many Quebec observers and hockey fans, this statement is seen as an unfair, even insulting, reduction of the merit of the Bécancour-born goalie.

As if being Francophone was a free pass, a card played for political reasons or regional representation, and not the reflection of hard work and real talent.

The Canadiens’ Goalie Will Have the Chance to Prove Otherwise

Montembeault, who has established himself as a reliable goalie on a young rebuilding team in Montreal, has never claimed special treatment. His journey, full of obstacles, shows steady and deserved progress.

His eventual selection as the third goalie for a highly competitive team like Team Canada should be based on his performance, not his accent.

If Montembeault earns his spot on Team Canada, it won’t be because he speaks French. It will be because he stops pucks. Period.