New Evidence Reveals Daniel’s Cover-Up for Malehya | Lilly and Jack Sullivan
don’t attack Malaya because her mental health is
you know it’s gonna be reflected on her daughter
so I don’t want anyone attacking Malaya anymore
I’m just staying as hopeful as possible
I want them home I wanna hold them
and I want them home

what happened was we woke up
I heard them playing in the next room beside us
and I was drifting in and out of sleep
and they’re not the type of kids that
we tell them not to go outside on their own
we always make sure that we’re out there with them
watching them
and they happened to just get out that sliding door
and we can’t hear it when it opens
and they were outside playing
but we weren’t aware of it at the time
every day when I wake up it’s just
feels like I’m reliving a nightmare of May 2nd
on the morning of May 2nd
two children

vanished into the dense woods of Nova Scotia
Lily age six
and her four year old brother Jack
their disappearance triggered a massive search effort
desperate prayers and a flood of unanswered questions
but beneath the surface of official statements
and community vigils
something else has been stirring
something quieter and more unsettling
what if Daniel Martel the man who searched the woods
gave interviews and pleaded for calm
wasn’t hiding his own guilt but someone else’s
what if the truth about what happened that morning
isn’t buried in deception
but in misplaced Protection
this
episode explores a hypothesis no one wants to believe
yet one that refuses to be ignored
it does not accuse it does not convict
but it asks you to look closer
because until Lily and Jack are found
everyone remains a suspect
including the one who may have stayed silent for love
May 2nd began like any other
but within a matter of hours
it would become a date etched in dread
at 6:17 a m
a call was made to the school
Lily and Jack were home sick
their mother was awake alert enough to excuse them
but if she was up how did she not hear the back door
the sliding door
the one she later claimed made no sound at all
between 8 a m
and 9:40 a m
the stories begin to fracture
Daniel Martel says
he saw Lily entering and exiting the bedroom
multiple times
but maleahya recalls something else entirely
a suffocating quiet not the kind that brings peace
but the kind that chills you to the bone
she says that’s when she knew something was wrong
yet no one called 9 1 1
not at 8:30 not even at 9:45
it wasn’t until around 10:00am
that police were finally contacted
by then Daniel says he’d already covered over 20 acres
searching on foot
alone in the woods before any official search had begun
what exactly happened in that missing window
when both parents are home and both children disappear
silence becomes more than eerie it becomes evidence
by all accounts Daniel was a quiet man
he worked part time just one day a week
at a local lumber mill financially unstable
socially withdrawn and according to some
quietly controlling
he wasn’t the kind of figure you noticed in a crowd
but in the aftermath of Lily and Jack
Sullivan’s disappearance
he became someone no one could ignore
from the beginning Daniel appeared cooperative
while the children’s mother
Maleah Brooks Murray retreated from the public eye
Daniel stepped forward he gave interviews
he talked to media
he walked the camera crews through the moments
before the children vanished
and at first glance
his transparency seemed like innocence
but look closer and cracks begin to form
Daniel’s speech patterns betray a man
both rehearsed and conflicted
in nearly every public statement
he echoes Malachi’s phrases
sometimes almost word for word
a linguistic reflection
that suggests either deep alignment
or prearranged storytelling
when he describes Lily he uses the past tense
she liked girly things a phrase simple enough
but weighted with implication
why speak of your stepdaughter in past tense
if you still believe she’s alive
even more curious
is Daniel’s tendency to speak in collective terms
we realized the house was too quiet
not I realized not she realized
the use of we obscures accountability
diffuses ownership of events
this shared language
might hint at solidarity with Malaya
or at a coordinated effort to
protect a version of events
Daniel often centers himself in the narrative
his throat was sore he ran through the woods
he searched for hours
he makes sure we know how far he went
and how hard he tried we were searching
we covered every everywhere possible
even in the first day we did
even with me running through the woods
I was ahead of the helicopters
and ahead of the drones and stuff like that screaming
screaming as loud as I can
and just until my throat hurt
running through water that was up to my waist
and as soon as I got back
I wasn’t allowed back in the woods until a man in
dressed in military outfit said
I could go back into the woods
but the focus rarely stays on Lily and Jack
instead it circles back to him
his experience his effort
his pain
he even claimed to have passed a polygraph test
but the RCMP never confirmed this
you mentioned last time we chatted
that you’d offer to do a polygraph test
that is correct and that already happened
that has happened right
and did you get results from that yet
I do have results
and I don’t know if I can share those results
but but they were good in my favor
will say that no documentation
no witness no results
a statement made to bolster credibility
yet lacking all verification
if it was a lie it was a bold one
if it was true why no official acknowledgment
what changed on May 3rd
Malaia’s mother arrived and from that moment
things began to shift Daniel’s tone altered
his narrative evolved was there a prior agreement
a shared story and understanding
that began to unravel under new influence
some believe so
one telling moment came in a now deleted live stream
where Daniel’s cousin defended him passionately
while blaming Malaya and her family
for obstructing the truth
this sudden redirection felt less like clarity
and more like strategy
an attempt to rally sympathy for Daniel
while painting Malaya as unstable
possibly even dangerous
there are signs Daniel may not be the perpetrator
he’s visible he’s vocal
he’s seemingly open to questioning
but is that transparency or is it deflection
could it be that he’s protecting someone
could it be that silence isn’t just absence
it’s loyalty his language holds more clues
he frequently uses passive constructions
if someone took them instead of if they were taken
it creates distance it removes agency
it avoids commitment to anyone theory
while subtly implying abduction
and in a chilling comment
he said if she hadn’t left
this wouldn’t have happened
not a mourning parent
a man assigning blame and once again
not to himself
the behavioral shifts are equally telling
in early statements Daniel
seemed to share a singular perspective with Malia
but post May 3rd his tone changed
accusatory self defensive
he leaked messages
blaming her for not watching the kids
publicly stated he feared for Meadow’s safety
don’t attack Malia because her mental health is
you know it’s gonna be reflected on our daughter
so I don’t want anyone attacking Malia anymore
and while he still pleaded with the public
to stop attacking Malia he did so with caveats
as if protecting her only to protect himself
perhaps
Daniel Martel isn’t guilty of harming Lily and Jack
but guilt isn’t always about action
sometimes it’s about inaction
about what you knew and when
about what you said or didn’t say
when the truth could have changed everything
the more you listen to Daniel
the more you realize he might be speaking from inside
a broken pact one that was once built on secrecy
but shattered
the moment a new player entered the scene
the mother of the woman he loved
a woman who may have drawn a line
he was no longer willing or able to cross
in the early days of may
deep in the woods of Nova Scotia
two young children
six year old Lily and four year old Jack
vanished without a trace there were no footprints
no surveillance footage no signs of a struggle
just a mother standing at the threshold of her home
saying the children must have wandered off
that’s what she told others
that’s what Malaya Brooks Murray claimed
and yet from the moment her story began
it didn’t feel quite right
Maleah was a young mother of three
described by those around her as overwhelmed
and possibly unwell
there had already been quiet concerns
reports of an unstable home
mental health struggles and parenting challenges
whispers that hinted at something frayed
just beneath the surface
but still nothing that foretold what would happen next
and certainly
nothing that explained the stillness in her voice
according to her account
the children walked out the back door
sometime around 9:30 a m
she said the door was silent
that she didn’t hear it
she claimed she thought they were still resting
but earlier that same morning
she had already informed the school
the children were sick and would be staying home
if she knew they were home
why hadn’t she seen them why hadn’t she heard them
why was the first instinct to assume they ran off
not to search the immediate home
not to panic not to shout their names
but perhaps
the most chilling moment came not in what she said
but in how quickly she said it
within 48 hours of the disappearance
Malehaya was calling her children angels
a word that parents usually avoid at all costs
unless they’ve reached the unthinkable conclusion
for most it’s a word reserved for memorials
a word spoken in whispers months
sometimes years after closure
but for Mala Hayah it came immediately
almost rehearsed
as if grief had skipped denial entirely
and landed somewhere far more practiced
and then came another shift
I believe they were taken
she later said but there was no evidence to support it
no vehicle seen no footprints leading to a road
no tire tracks no screams nothing
just a theory tossed into the public with no follow up
no appeal no tears
as scrutiny grew Malaia’s behavior
became even more difficult to reconcile
she stopped
responding to the children’s paternal grandmother
her online presence thinned
the very woman who should have been demanding answers
instead grew silent and then in the background
something else began to move
a force that for many would explain everything
her mother arrived sometime in the afternoon of May 2nd
Maleahia’s mother stepped into the story
and with her came a notable shift
communications with key people were severed
text messages stopped emotional tone changed
a voice that had once been subdued
now vanished completely
the working theory that Maleah and her partner Daniel
may have had a prior agreement
a narrative crafted between them
one meant to protect someone or something
but her mother’s arrival may have altered the plan
taken control and what followed
was the unraveling of that alleged arrangement
Daniel Martel
who once spoke publicly in Malehaya’s defense
soon began leaking texts that told a different story
he claimed she wasn’t caring for the children
that they were wild under her watch
that he had concerns all along
a notable departure from his earlier stance
where he had begged the public not to attack her
fearing she might harm their youngest child Meadow
he had once said she made him the happiest man alive
now she had blocked his number
the timing is hard to ignore
just after Malachi’s mother arrived
Daniel changed his tone
just after that moment
Malachi cut ties with everyone except her inner circle
and what began as a disappearance
quickly morphed into something more psychological
more layered
from the outside Daniel Martel appeared shattered
he cried on interviews
begged the public to stop attacking Malia Brooks Murray
and repeatedly claimed the happiest time of his life
was when she and the children were still by his side
but behind the emotional appeals
and filtered recollections
something didn’t add up he wasn’t just defending her
he was shielding her and as more details emerge
the question becomes impossible to ignore why
there were already signs that Malia was struggling
three young children reports of an unstable environment
and a possible history of postpartum depression
or dissociation if that’s true
if something heartbreaking happened
in the grip of a breakdown
Daniel may have found himself
trapped between two impossible roles
protector and witness in this theory
his silence wasn’t complicity
it was paralysis
and in the hours before Maleah’s mother arrived
he may have been desperately
trying to hold a narrative together
that neither of them could live with
then came the shift
after the arrival of Malachi’s mother on May 2nd
everything changed Daniel’s tone pivoted
the messages began to shift blame
suddenly he leaked texts accusing Malaya of negligence
said the children were wild under her care
a stunning reversal from the man who had
just days earlier
pleaded with the internet to stop harassing her
it raised a haunting possibility
was he trying to protect himself now
had an early plan to defend her
falling apart the moment someone else took control
because
while the public search was scaled back by the RCMP
the serious crimes unit continued digging
that alone
suggested the authorities suspected something deeper
something off script
and if the tragedy wasn’t accidental
but the result of shared responsibility neglect
distraction or worse
then Daniel may not be the silent hero he claimed to be
it’s possible both parents failed in their duty
one may have crossed the line
the other simply looked away
whether it was fear of losing custody
of their infant daughter Meadow
fear of prosecution or fear of confronting the truth
silence becomes a survival tactic
a form of self preservation cloaked in compassion
but there’s a third darker theory
one rooted in emotional dependency
throughout Daniel’s statements
he often repeats fond memories of Maleahia
especially their beach trips together
he clings to moments of normality
that kind of romantic recall can be a red flag
it suggests someone
who hasn’t fully separated from their emotional bond
someone still tethered by guilt
nostalgia or denial
perhaps Daniel couldn’t see her as dangerous
even if the facts demanded it
or worse
perhaps he could and still chose to protect her anyway
if Malachi was manipulative
emotionally unstable or controlling
Daniel’s Protection may not be chivalry
it might be Learned helplessness
a cycle of emotional dependency
where denial becomes a coping mechanism
in silence the price of connection
ultimately none of these theories on their own
can explain everything
but together they reveal a disturbing landscape
where tragedy may have been allowed to fester
in the shadows of loyalty
fear and emotional dysfunction
and the two people who could shed the most light
on what really happened that morning
in Nova Scotia
are either saying too much or nothing at all
and as the investigation stalled
and timelines unraveled attention turned inward
to the two adults in the home that morning
Malahia Brooks Murray the mother of three
and her partner Daniel Martel
what could explain two young children
disappearing into thin air
under the watch of two caregivers
to find that answer
we must explore not accusations but possibilities
theories born not from conspiracy
but from human weakness
emotional cracks
panic and quiet choices that grow louder over time
theory a a postpartum crisis and a panicked cover up
it begins with a woman on the edge
by all accounts Malaya was exhausted
raising three young children in an unstable environment
with mounting psychological strain
there were whispers of postpartum depression
maybe even dissociation in this scenario
something snaps the kids are being loud
perhaps unruly and in a moment of overwhelming emotion
a tragic mistake is made
not premeditated but irreversible
the parallels are chillingly familiar
in the Jonbenet Ramsey case
one theory suggested that the 6 year old’s death
was accidental a fatal head injury
during a fit of parental anger or carelessness
followed by a staged Ransom note
and a misdirection campaign
could something similar have happened here
if Maleah was harmed the children intentionally or not
Daniel may have walked in on the aftermath
and in that moment he didn’t call the police
he didn’t tell the truth he chose to protect her
whether out of love fear or pure panic
the silence began and once it started
it became impossible to reverse
theory B an accident they couldn’t admit
the forest surrounding the home is dense
and disorienting
ponds and creeks thread through the underbrush
in one of his interviews
Daniel uses the phrase dive into
a slip of the tongue perhaps
but one that raises suspicion
could water have played a role
another theory suggests that something tragic
but unintentional happened to Lily and Jack
a drowning an injury
or more disturbingly a drug related incident
rumors swirled early on
about suspicious activity at the home
unusual traffic alleged parties
whispers of drug use
Daniel later denied any such events occurred
but if an accidental overdose or exposure was involved
it would explain a rushed and covert response
under this theory both Daniel and Maleiah are complicit
not in causing the accident
but in hiding it a joint decision to stage the scene
to mislead police to begin a search for children
they already knew would not be found
not because they were taken
but because they were gone
theory C unpacked
broken by a third party perhaps there was a plan
a story rehearsed a cover up built on mutual silence
but then something changed
on the afternoon of May 2nd
Maleah’s mother arrived and shortly after that
the tone shifted
communication between Maleah
and the children’s paternal grandmother
stopped abruptly
Daniel’s behavior evolved
he leaked messages suggesting neglect
subtle blame began to surface
this shift may indicate that a fragile pact was broken
that Maleah under her mother’s influence
changed the narrative or refused to maintain the lie
and Daniel now exposed
began repositioning himself
not as the partner of a grieving mother
but as a father
trying to keep custody of his youngest child
a man who once said he was happiest with Maleah
now blocked from contact
his loyalty replaced with subtle self preservation
each theory is incomplete on its own
but together they offer a haunting portrait
of what may have gone wrong
not just in the home but in the silence that followed
whether born from panic guilt or emotional codependence
the actions of those closest to Lily and Jack
may have buried more than just the truth
and in the end
the real mystery may not be where the children went
but how far two people would go
to keep anyone from knowing
if Daniel Martel is protecting Malahia Brooks Murray
whether out of loyalty fear or guilt
then that silence isn’t just emotional
it’s evidence
and it may be the key that unlocks the entire case
RCMP have publicly confirmed
that there are no witnesses to an abduction
no concrete signs of forced entry
struggle or escape
that doesn’t mean the children weren’t taken
it means there is no proof they were
and that distinction changes everything
because when you strip away the
idea of a stranger danger scenario
what you’re left with is a painful possibility
that what happened happened from within
the physical search has now been scaled back
helicopters bloodhounds
drones all withdrawn
but the Serious Crime unit hasn’t stopped
that tells us something critical
this is no longer just about a wilderness search
it’s about truth withheld
stories that don’t line up
reactions that came too quickly or not quickly enough
and when you start to weigh the inconsistencies
the changing narratives
and the sudden silence that followed
the arrival of Maleahaya’s mother
a chilling theory emerges
that there may have been a plan
or at the very least an understanding
one that fractured under pressure
the emotional fog surrounding this case
has made it nearly impossible to tell the difference
between accident and intent
between a moment of tragic crisis
and a deliberate deception
and when there’s no transparency
no consistency and no cooperation
those two possibilities
begin to look dangerously similar
why does it matter if Daniel is protecting malahia
because in cases like this
time is not neutral
every day that passes without clarity
erodes the chance for recovery
closure or accountability
if something was hidden
if anything was staged or concealed
then the truth isn’t just waiting
it’s being withheld
and that means someone could still come forward
someone could still break the silence
whether this was an accident buried under panic
or a choice buried under fear
the outcome remains the same
two children gone a family shattered
a community caught between hope and horror
but if there was a cover up
it can still be undone
because silence may protect someone for a time
but it has never protected the truth
Daniel may not be hiding his own guilt
he may be hiding Maleah’s truth
and if that’s the case
the window to save Lily and Jack may have closed
long before the 9 1
1 call was ever made
covering for someone isn’t always a crime
but it is always dangerous
especially when silence hides the fate of a child
if you know anything now is the time to speak
justice for Lily and Jack starts with truth
don’t let silence be the final word
subscribe
share and help us bring the light back to this case
thank you for watching True Crime Stories hour
if you enjoyed this story
don’t forget to like share
subscribe and hit the notification bell