Landsdown Station, Nova Scotia – After months of silence surrounding the disappearance of Lily Sullivan, 6, and her brother Jack, 4, a new witness has come forward with explosive claims that could change the course of the investigation.

The children vanished on the night of May 1 without a trace. No forced entry was reported at the Sullivan home. No footprints in the mud, no signs of struggle. Until now, the case had been defined by uncertainty and silence—both from investigators and the family at the center of the mystery.

A Neighbor Breaks His Silence

A man living just two houses away says he heard a heated argument that evening. According to his account, the fight involved Daniel Martel, the children’s stepfather, and their mother, Malaya Brooks Murray.

He recalls a man’s voice shouting: “You’re not taking them.” Moments later, he says he heard Malaya respond: “They’re leaving with me tomorrow, whether you like it or not.”

The neighbor claims the argument ended with a door slamming—“like an ending”—followed by an unsettling silence.

For months, he kept quiet. He watched helicopters, search dogs, and volunteers comb the area, but said nothing until recently. He admits he stayed silent because he “didn’t want to get involved,” but now says guilt has kept him awake at night.

A Timeline Rewritten

If his account is accurate, it undermines Daniel Martel’s version of events. Martel has consistently claimed May 1 was an ordinary evening: pizza with the family in the afternoon, some yard work, then an early bedtime for the children.

But according to the new witness, around 7:30 p.m., Martel and Brooks Murray were outside, arguing specifically about who would take the children the next day. That transforms what was thought to be a peaceful night into one marked by volatility and conflict.

Investigators now face a chilling possibility: that the children’s disappearance was not random, but rooted in a custody dispute or a planned escape that escalated out of control.

Motives Under Scrutiny

Several theories have emerged from the neighbor’s testimony:

Custody conflict: Malaya may have been planning to leave Daniel and take the children with her, sparking confrontation.

Fear of exposure: If Malaya threatened to reveal alleged neglect, substance abuse, or CPS involvement, Daniel may have reacted to protect himself.

Escape gone wrong: Malaya could have been planning to flee with the children, only for Daniel to intervene.

Each scenario points to the same conclusion: the disappearance may not have been an accident, but the result of a decision made inside the home.

A Divided Community

The witness’s decision to come forward has split Landsdown Station.

Some residents feel vindicated, believing this confirms suspicions that something happened inside the Sullivan home.

Others doubt his story, questioning why he waited months to speak and whether his memory has been influenced by media coverage.

The town, once united in searching for Lily and Jack, is now fractured. Neighbors avoid each other, whispers spread through grocery aisles, and suspicion grows.

Investigators Revisit Leads

There is unconfirmed talk that the RCMP may be quietly reviewing phone records and GPS data near a wooden bridge—a site that had earlier drawn attention when a star-shaped sticker, identical to those on Lily’s jacket, was found nearby.

Whether this witness will push authorities to reopen parts of the investigation remains unclear.

Truth or Distraction?

For now, all that exists is his word. There is no recording, no physical evidence, only testimony offered months after the fact.

That raises the central question: is this man a key witness unlocking hidden truths, or just another distraction in a case already strained by rumor and speculation?

Two Children Still Missing

What remains unchanged is the most urgent fact: Lily and Jack Sullivan are still missing.

The new testimony may prove to be the first crack in a wall of silence—or just more noise in a story already burdened by shadows. Either way, the disappearance of two young children remains unsolved, and the search for truth continues.