LAST UPDATE: They Had the Tech to Find Them—But It Came Too Late | Lilly and Jack Sullivan
investigators remain committed to exploring
all possibilities
surrounding the children’s disappearance
we want to thank all those who provided tips
and information
please know
that we’re fully
engaged in finding out what happened to Lily
and Jack The Truth Verification Unit is engaged
uh there’s multiple facets to those investigations and
and those experts are examining
every question and answer that those individuals
are providing and it could guide the investigation
it was the kind of disappearance that defied logic
on May 2nd 2,025
two young siblings Lily
just 6 and her little brother Jack
only 4 vanished from their rural home on Garlock Road
Nova Scotia no one saw them leave
no cameras tracked their movements
no physical evidence marked a path
days turned into weeks and yet the mystery deepened
RCMP stopped short of declaring an abduction
but their actions said otherwise
specialized units were quietly deployed
polygraph teams forensic analysts
behavioral profilers even underwater recovery crews
each brought their own lens to the case
but with no suspects named
and the parent stories unraveling under scrutiny
a new question emerged
were the right tools used in the right way
and if so why do we still have no answers
today we explore each unit’s mission
and what they may have missed
in the search for Lily and Jack Sullivan
what followed
was not an immediate search and rescue blitz
instead it was a slow
uncertain mobilization hesitant
fragmented and fatally delayed
and at the heart of that delay
was one name the Northeast Nova RCMP Major Crime Unit
this unit wasn’t just any team
it was designed to lead Canada’s most critical criminal
investigations to deploy instantly
to secure scenes to question suspects
and to coordinate a unified strategy
across departments but in this case
its presence was missing when it mattered most
for days the crime unit operated remotely
reviewing tips and timelines from a distance
and while they sat behind screens
any potential evidence at the scene may have been lost
disturbed by volunteers
overlooked in plain sight or worse
deliberately erased
if they had acted swiftly
boots on the ground specialists embedded at the scene
they could have begun targeted interviews
with those closest to the children
they could have cross
verified the statements of the mother
and stepfather
both of whom later offered conflicting timelines
and vague accounts
behavioral cues could have been logged in real time
phone records traced before deletion
even the integrity of digital evidence
might have been preserved
but the real failure wasn’t just in timing
it was in coordination
the Major Crime Unit
should have served as the central command
aligning search dogs forensic teams
underwater recovery and digital experts under a single
investigative umbrella
instead silos formed
leads drifted and the initial confusion gave suspects
if they exist time to breathe
to hide and perhaps to disappear along with the truth
by the time the unit truly took control
the trail had already begun to cool
what could have been a focused manhunt
became a desperate plea for tips
and in that void
the most terrifying question still echoes
had the full force of the Major Crime Unit arrived
just 48 hours earlier would Lily and Jack be home today
it’s the test that no one wants to take
but in cases where answers are scarce
and time is the enemy
the truth verification section becomes a last resort
known to most as the polygraph unit
this team isn’t just listening to what people say
they’re listening to what their bodies betray
in the case of Lily and Jack Sullivan
this unit was activated quietly
cautiously after the children vanished without a trace
from their home on Garlock Road
and at the center of that examination stood one man
Daniel Martel the children’s stepfather
he agreed to take the test
the RCMP confirmed it but then nothing
no results released no public clarity
just silence fueling rumors and multiplying doubt
in high stakes disappearances
polygraphs aren’t used to prove guilt
they’re used to reveal what someone knows
but refuses to say the science is controversial yes
but when used strategically
polygraph results can spotlight deception
uncover withheld details and most importantly
expose guilty knowledge that’s not a confession
it’s recognition a reaction to something
only someone involved would understand
what questions were asked during Martell’s exam
which ones did he hesitate to answer
which ones triggered a physiological spike
and what about Maleah the children’s mother
as of now it’s unclear whether she was ever tested
why was she protected or was there simply no follow up
had this unit been empowered to go deeper
to follow those tremors of discomfort
with further questioning
or even to pressure reluctant participants
we might be closer to the truth
instead the public was left with a dangerous void
one where suspicion festers
in the absence of transparency
if RCMP had shared more not sensitive details
but even the basic direction of results
it could have eased public concern
or redirected energy where it belonged
but the silence has done the opposite
in a case where every interview matters
the polygraph wasn’t a tool of confirmation
it was missed opportunity
because sometimes it’s not just about who lies
it’s about what they lie about
and when it comes to missing children
even a single concealed truth
can mean the difference between finding them
or never knowing what happened at all
in an age
where nearly every moment leaves a digital footprint
the silence surrounding the disappearance of Lily
and Jack Sullivan
is more than haunting it’s suspicious
on May 2nd, 2000 twenty five
two children vanished without a trace
from their quiet home in rural Nova Scotia
no witnesses no security footage
no forensic evidence left behind
but what if the real story wasn’t out in the woods
but inside a phone a cloud backup or a deleted message
that’s where Digital Forensic Services comes in
this elite team doesn’t chase suspects in the field
they hunt ghosts in data in the Sullivan case
both the mother’s and stepfather’s phones were seized
that alone tells us
the RCMP saw value in digital evidence
but what did they find more importantly
what was deleted if deployed to full capacity
this unit could recover wiped texts
analyze GPS trails
and reconstruct movements down to the minute
did either parent visit a remote area
near the time the children vanished
were there deleted searches
unsent messages
what about Bluetooth activity tied to the family’s ATV
the same vehicle Daniel Martel claimed
he used during his personal search
every sensor every ping
every paused step could reveal a contradiction
and it doesn’t stop there
residential security systems from nearby homes
if accessed and synchronized
might not show the children
but could reveal inconsistencies in movement
timing and lighting conditions
even background reflections in photos
smart home activity logs
or audio files from synced cloud devices
could tell a story that human memory forgets
or deliberately alters
perhaps the most powerful capability this team has
isn’t just in recovering what was lost
but in replacing speculation with an objective timeline
a timeline built not from memory or emotion
but from cold digital fact
one that either confirms the parents’accounts
or dismantles them in a case where words fail
devices speak
but only if someone knows how and dares to listen
had this unit been granted full investigative reach
and transparency the screen might have cracked long ago
revealing not just where Lily and Jack went
but who tried so hard to hide it
some truths aren’t hidden in the evidence
they’re buried in the way someone tells their story
when Lily and Jack Sullivan vanished without a trace
from their home on Gerlock Road
the first instinct was to search the woods
the lakes the fields
but the real clues
may have been standing in front of cameras
the entire time enter the Behavioral Sciences Group
a specialized unit trained to detect deception
not through hard evidence
but through the soft tremors of human behavior
every nervous blink every word choice
every time a name is avoided
or a sentence shifts into past tense
it all means something and in this case
it meant everything
from the moment the stepfather
Daniel Martel gave his first public statement
trained eyes began to notice the cracks
he rarely used the children’s names
he described them in the past tense
his focus drifted not to the search
but to his own emotional state
later during the prayer vigil
the mother Malehaya
was conspicuously absent
and in live streams from family and friends
concern gave way to control
emotion felt
curated spontaneity replaced by performance
the behavioral sciences team doesn’t accuse
it observes it builds psychological profiles
matches speech patterns to stress cues
and identifies leakage
when suppressed truth slips out unintentionally
if empowered to conduct a full review
they would have dissected every interview
frame by frame highlighting contradictions
redirections and linguistic red flags
more than that their analysis
could have informed the RCMP’s interview strategy
should a suspect be shown photos of the children
to provoke a genuine emotional reaction
should they be challenged with silence
to see what fills it these aren’t just tactics
they’re science backed techniques to make truth surface
when words fail in a case without blood
without prints without footage
behavior becomes evidence
and when the people closest to the victim
seem the furthest from the truth
it’s not a matter of opinion
it’s a matter of analysis
had the Behavioral Science Group taken center stage
from day 1 we might not be guessing what happened
we might already know who was lying and why
in cases like this silence isn’t just deafening
it’s misleading and still
water that can lie better than any suspect
when Lily and Jack Sullivan vanished without a trace
one of the first moves by the RCMP
was to scan the nearby landscape fields
trails outbuildings
but soon their focus turned to the water
The Underwater Recovery Unit was deployed
to search the lakes
streams and ponds surrounding the Sullivan home
their mission to recover anything
anything
that might tell the story these woods refused to share
a child’s shoe a piece of torn fabric
a backpack even the smallest object
could become a beacon in this darkness
but water distorts more than vision
it hides evidence swallows timelines
and if someone knew what they were doing
can be used to erase entire chapters of a crime
that’s where sonar
imaging and submersible technology come in
with the right equipment
search teams can detect unnatural disturbances
on the lake bed map irregular terrain
and identify foreign objects
long buried beneath the surface
the problem in this case
those advanced tools weren’t fully utilized
or if they were it hasn’t been disclosed
so we’re left to ask
was something missed beneath the ripples
was the water treated not as a hazard
but as a hiding place
because here’s the chilling reality
if someone placed evidence in that water
if someone used the stillness to their advantage
then every passing day makes recovery less likely
algae grows silt shifts
and the story that object could tell
fades with each current
had the underwater recovery unit been equipped
with autonomous drones
ground penetrating sonar or Thermal sensors
we might be talking about what they found
not what they might have overlooked
and if their deployment had been extended
or even returned to
in later stages of the investigation
perhaps we’d know more now than we did in those first
desperate weeks
sometimes monsters don’t leave footprints
sometimes they leave ripples
and if we don’t look deep enough
if we don’t listen to what the water is
still trying to say we risk letting them vanish
just like the children did
in missing persons cases
time is the enemy and scent is the first thing to die
within hours rain
wind and human activity
can erase the invisible trail left behind by fleeing
feet or carried body that’s why when children vanish
the K9 unit isn’t just helpful
it’s vital
and in the disappearance of Lily and Jack Sullivan
the clock had already begun to betray them
the police dog services
often referred to as the K9 unit
were brought in early
their trained noses are capable of picking up a child
scent on grass
gravel even concrete
but what they found or more importantly
didn’t find only deepened the mystery
according to reports
the dogs failed to detect any scent trail
leaving the house no path into the woods
no signs of movement toward the road
just nothing if that’s true
it presents two terrifying possibilities
either the children never left on foot
or
someone wiped away their exit with chilling precision
and that’s where timing matters
experts agree
that the window to deploy scent tracking dogs
is razor thin
ideally within four to six hours of disappearance
any delay even by morning dew
or casual contamination from search volunteers
can compromise the trail in this case
it remains unclear
exactly how quickly the canines were brought in
or whether their deployment was limited
by environmental factors but one thing is certain
by the time the dogs were there
the scent the truth
may already have been gone
had the K9 unit been unleashed immediately
we might know today whether the children wandered
were carried or never left at all
their route could have been tracked
the father’s claim
that Lily and Jack walked out on their own
could have been tested not by emotion
but by evidence and perhaps most chilling of all
if there had been no scent at all
not even inside the home
that might have pointed toward a staging
a cover up in a story where everything is uncertain
scent is pure it cannot lie
but it can fade and once it does
so too
does our ability to follow the children’s last steps
until all we’re left with is silence and questions
some cases are too quiet no screams
no signs of struggle no open doors or shattered glass
just two missing children
Lily and Jack Sullivan
gone from their Nova Scotia home
without a single footprint pointing the way
when the evidence doesn’t speak
it falls to the minds trained to read between the lines
that’s where the Criminal Analysis Unit comes in
their mission isn’t to chase suspects down back alleys
it’s to map the invisible relationships
risk factors behavioral patterns
in a case like this
they become the architects of possibility
building profiles connecting dots
exposing contradictions
and in this tangled web of silence and suspicion
their role could be everything
imagine what they might uncover
a family tree built not with birthdays and addresses
but with histories of violence addictions death
who had access who had motive
who had something to lose if the truth came out
if fully deployed the unit could
build a behavioral matrix
that weighs opportunity against psychological strain
helping narrow not just who might have done something
but why and how they might have tried to cover it up
did someone panic was this an act of desperation
or was it calculated planned
even rehearsed
they could also apply predictive models
using financial records mental health histories
even school and community reports
not to accuse blindly but to identify pressure points
because sometimes the truth hides in patterns
not places in a case where physical evidence is scarce
and the adults closest to the children
give conflicting uncomfortable accounts
where polygraphs are taken but never revealed
and where statements are drenched in past tense
and passive language
the work of the Criminal Analysis Unit
could focus the investigation
with surgical precision
and perhaps most important of all
they can dismantle the illusion of randomness
they can take a case

that appears to be a tragic mystery
and reveal it for what it truly might be
a crime of opportunity of proximity
of silence a crime born not in the shadows
but within the four walls where the children once lived
because in the absence of clear answers
we must turn to clear minds
and if this unit is watching closely enough
they might already know where to look next
they didn’t just disappear
that’s the hardest truth to face
in the case of Lily and Jack Sullivan
two children ages 6 and 4
don’t vanish into thin air
especially not from their own home on a quiet
rural road in Nova Scotia
so if they didn’t wander off
and if no one saw them taken
what really happened
when a case grows cold in the physical world
no witnesses no security footage
no conclusive forensic trail
it’s the digital underworld that must be searched next
that’s where the Canadian Center for Child Protection
or C3P becomes an essential partner
this agency doesn’t wear badges or canvas for us
instead it works in data
massive databases of missing children
flagged IP addresses dark web activity
and the shadow networks
no parent ever wants to imagine
if there was ever a case where C3P
s reach could make a difference
it’s this one
through photo recognition and biometric data comparison
they could attempt to match Lily and Jack’s images
with any unidentified child spotted online
whether in surveillance footage
private forums or disturbing corners of the internet
where trafficking thrives
it’s not about assuming the worst
it’s about not leaving any possibility unexamined
their experts are also trained to detect
and dismantle networks that distribute
child exploitation material
if even a whisper of this case crossed
those digital thresholds C3P would know how to find it
and in doing so they might find more than just a clue
they might find a lead that breaks the silence
but their role isn’t only technical
C3P also plays a vital role in public education
and media responsibility in a case like this
flooded with online speculation
misinformation and conspiracy theories
a voice of clarity is critical
they can help ensure the conversation
stays focused on finding the children
not feeding chaos
and most importantly
they bring a lens of child Protection to every theory
every headline every decision
not just justice for the public
not just truth for the system
but safety for Lily for Jack
and for every child who could be next
because when a child goes missing
you don’t just search with flashlights and k nines
you search with code with algorithms
with vigilance that never sleeps
and if C3P is watching the digital world
as closely as it should then maybe
just maybe

we’ll catch a signal where no one thought to listen
it begins with silence no footsteps
no screams no trail of breadcrumbs
just two children Lily and Jack Sullivan gone
erased from the landscape like a breath in winter air
and while the world waits for answers
one question echoes across the national system
have they turned up somewhere else
and no one knows it yet
that’s where the National Center for Missing Persons
and unidentified Remains or ncmpur
holds a power most people never think about
until it’s far too late in cases like this
where physical leads have crumbled
and timelines fracture
under the weight of contradiction
ncmpa becomes the silent vault
holding Canada’s most tragic puzzles
the missing and the unnamed
if someone somewhere finds human remains bones
clothing fragments overlooked in a clearing
or discovered during a construction dig
ncmperr is where that information should converge
through DNA databases
dental records and cross provincial case matching
they can connect what once seemed unrelated
a tiny sock a clump of hair
a single drop of blood
any of it could bridge the gap between the unknown
and the unresolved
but this only works if the connections are made in time
if RCMP or local investigators
consistently upload forensic findings
soil samples fabric fibers
partial DNA from recovered items
N C m

per can initiate silent comparisons
across hundreds of other missing person cases
or unidentified remains
without this synergy data just sleeps
and in a case like Lily and Jack’s
where the terrain is dense
the water is deep and the possibility of buried
or submerged evidence is chillingly real
a missed cross reference could mean losing that one
fragile chance to bring them home
or to bring the truth to light
NCM pore also plays a pivotal role in long term
cold case resolution
should months pass and bodies be discovered without ID
their systems may be the only thread
tying back to a disappearance
buried by time or bureaucracy
because if the answers aren’t at the surface
they might be hidden in the nation’s deepest vault
the question is
will someone open it before it’s too late
in a case like Lily and Jack’s
time has been the greatest enemy
but with unified relentless coordination
that time can be reversed
lies confronted gaps closed
and most importantly a truth long buried
forced into the light because justice doesn’t wait
and neither should we
thank you for watching True Crime Stories hour