The New York Yankees’ return to the World Series for the first time since 2009 marked a significant milestone for the franchise, yet the landscape of baseball continues to evolve rapidly around them. While the Los Angeles Dodgers have commanded attention with their unprecedented offseason acquisitions, the Yankees find themselves pursuing a more nuanced approach to sustained success.

Despite losing Juan Soto to their crosstown rivals, the Yankees have fortified their roster through strategic additions like Devin Williams, Cody Bellinger, Max Fried, and Paul Goldschmidt. However, the team’s long-term prosperity may ultimately depend on the development of their promising young talent throughout the 2025 season and beyond.

Austin Wells – Developing into a complete backstop

Yankees
2024 Stats: .229/.322/.395, 13 HR, 105 wRC+

The emergence of Austin Wells behind the plate represents a critical development for the Yankees’ future. His defensive metrics have impressed significantly, placing him in the 96th percentile for pitch framing while demonstrating notable improvement in pitcher management. The departure of Jose Trevino creates a clear path for Wells to establish himself as the primary catcher in 2025.

Offensively, Wells showed promise in his first complete season, though his power potential remains partially untapped. His swing mechanics, particularly suited for generating lift, align perfectly with Yankee Stadium’s right-field dimensions. Further refinement during the offseason could unlock additional power production in his developing bat.

Anthony Volpe – Defensive excellence seeking offensive balance

NY POST
2024 Stats: .243/.293/.364, 12 HR, 28 SB, 86 wRC+

While Anthony Volpe hasn’t yet reached his offensive ceiling, his defensive excellence has already established him as one of baseball’s premier shortstops. His 3.4 fWAR in 2024 demonstrated his overall value, driven by exceptional fielding and superior baserunning skills.

The offensive side presents clear areas for improvement, particularly in contact quality. A 50.2% ground ball rate and declining ISO from .174 to .121 limited his power output. Success against breaking pitches and mechanical refinements could help the 24-year-old realize his potential as a dynamic offensive threat. His skill set suggests 20 home runs and 20 stolen bases remain achievable benchmarks.

Jasson Dominguez – Potential must tap opportunity

NYP
2024 Stats (MiLB): .314/.376/.504, 11 HR, 16 SB, 135 wRC+

The anticipation surrounding Jasson Domínguez remains substantial, though perspective is crucial regarding the 21-year-old outfielder’s development. With 50 games of Triple-A experience, patience becomes essential, even as his potential continues to captivate.

Domínguez’s toolkit features premium speed, developing power, and strong defensive capabilities. Steamer projections anticipate a .249/.326/.418 line with 18 HR and 18 SB for 2025, numbers that would significantly strengthen the Yankees’ lineup depth. His adaptation to major league pitching will prove crucial in determining his immediate impact.

Oswaldo Cabrera – Versatility should translate into reliability

NYY
2024 Stats: .247/.296/.365, 8 HR, 88 wRC+

Championship teams require versatile contributors, and Oswaldo Cabrera exemplifies this essential role. The switch-hitter’s ability to manage six different positions effectively while providing reliable defense at each spot makes him an invaluable roster piece.

His offensive progression from a challenging 2023 campaign shows promise. While not a power threat, his excellent 89% zone contact rate and minimal 18.8% whiff rate suggest sustainable success as a contact-oriented hitter. His multi-positional capability mirrors the valuable utility role that has made players like DJ LeMahieu essential to successful teams.

Oswald Peraza – Critical juncture ahead

SL.com
2024 Stats (MiLB): .243/.343/.407, 16 HR, 25 SB, 99 wRC+

Oswald Peraza approaches a pivotal moment in his career, entering spring training without minor league options. A shoulder injury in 2024 disrupted his progression, resulting in extended time at Triple-A rather than establishing himself at the major league level.

While his power metrics showed a decline, including reduced exit velocity, a healthy offseason could facilitate a return to form. With uncertainty at third base, Peraza faces a crucial opportunity to claim regular playing time. His performance could significantly influence the Yankees’ infield configuration moving forward.

Ben Rice – Power potential to break out of reserve

Fox
2024 Stats: .171/.264/.349, 7 HR, 73 wRC+ (50 G)

Ben Rice‘s 2024 season demonstrated both promise and growing pains. Initially stepping in for Anthony Rizzo, he displayed impressive power before encountering late-season struggles.

Though Paul Goldschmidt’s arrival suggests a reduced immediate role, Rice’s raw power potential remains intriguing. His ability to provide bench strength or injury insurance, combined with strong minor-league performance, positions him as a valuable depth piece for 2025.

Young core key to Yankees’ sustained success

The Yankees‘ 2025 campaign will largely be defined by their young talent’s development. While the Dodgers’ aggressive acquisitions dominate headlines, the Yankees’ organizational health depends on successfully nurturing their internal prospects.

Significant progress from Wells, Volpe, and Domínguez would transform the lineup’s depth and dynamism. The establishment of Cabrera and Peraza as reliable contributors could resolve positional questions, while Rice’s emergence would add valuable depth.

The Yankees’ identity as baseball’s Evil Empire traditionally centered on marquee free-agent acquisitions and blockbuster trades. However, their 2025 success may ultimately hinge on a different approach—the maturation and impact of their homegrown talent base.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.